Death Row: two words that can send shivers down the spine.
We have all seen movies like The Green Mile or Dead Man Walking and the sense
that accompanies Death Row is that of deprivation, inhumanity and loss.
When u agree to do an internship with Amicus (sometimes known
as a death row internship), you know there is a real possibility that you will
visit inmates on death row, it’s just part of the job.
I had my first visit to death row, aka Unit 32 at MS State
Penitentiary, a few weeks ago. The State Penitentiary is located in Parchman.
It’s about a 3 hour drive north from Jackson which means an early start. The drive to Parchman is essentially a
straight line and I was happy to be driving as it is not the most exciting
scenery. Mississippi is a very rural state which means that much of the landscape
is flat farmland. In winter this results in a lot of brown – scrubland, dead
grass, and barren trees. What saved the drive for me was the bright sunshine and
blue sky.
I think part of me had been expecting Parchman to be an
impenetrable fortress, a bastion of death, an evil blockhouse thrust from the
depths of hell itself (just to be dramatic!). However, quite the reverse turned
out to be true. No guardhouses, or high impenetrable walls, just a big gate
staffed by guards. Inside the gate was a sign for ‘children playing’ and a
series of white clapboard houses, that presumably are homes to prison guards’
families. Not quite what I was expecting! The facility itself seemed to
comprise of a number of ‘units’ and ancillary buildings spread out over what I
can only imagine to have been many hectares. We drove past various units, down
a number of roads of flat scrubland until we arrived at Unit 32.
Another security check, akin to airport security, and we
were directed, through some outdoor caged corridors to the visitation area. As
a visitor, you don’t really get far into the unit. On your way in though you can see
the exercise cages. Cage is an apt term to use, as even in exercise they are
kept like animals. The cages are no bigger than cells and leave no room for any
form of exercise. What they offer, I suppose, is fresh air and the opportunity
to look up at the sky.
As part of my LLM I visited a number of prisons, Mountjoy
being one of them. For those of you unfamiliar with ‘The Joy’, Mountjoy is a
relic from the Victorian age. Based on the design of London’s Pentonville
prison, not much has changed at Mountjoy in the intervening years and inmates
are still subject to ‘slopping out’ and overcrowding. I found Mountjoy to be dark, dank, miserable
and generally scary - exactly what one imagines prisons to have been like in
the Victorian age (just not in the noughties).
Parchman, in
comparison, seemed practically hospitable. As I said, it was a bright sunny
day, and perhaps it affected my impression of the place, but the most striking thought
I had was that it was like an old hospital. White walls and linoleum floors; it
was just very clinical. To be fair, I am sure that on a grey day, it would be a different
story. I am also sure that behind the scenes things are not quite so bright and
visitor-friendly. Inmates spoke of leaking cells, limited access to showers and unkind guards,
of isolation, loneliness and fear.
Once inside the unit the visitation area is directly in
front of you: A glass paneled box, inside
of which are the ubiquitous glass-divided visitation booths. Inmates are
brought to the visitation room in shackles. The shackles remain on for the
duration of the visit; hands are bound at the wrists to a chain round the waist
and feet are chained to the floor. The cuffs at the wrists cut into the skin
and leave red marks.
Visits are so important for the moral of inmates. They spend
23 hours of the day in their cells with an hour allowed for exercise in the
cages. Many of the inmates don’t get many visitors and so attorney visits are a
real opportunity to get out of the cells and talk to people.
Over the course of about 2 hours I spoke to a number of our
clients. It was not easy. Those who know me know that small talk is not my
forte and what these men needed most was someone to just talk. Talk about
normal things, the world outside, music, TV and their families. Some were easy
to talk to, others weren’t. I was surprised by how upbeat and positive some of
the inmates were. I was surprised, in some ways, by how normal the conversations
were. We could have been friends in different lives. It was challenging though,
especially when talking to inmates who were having a bad time of it. Trying to
engage with them and take their minds off things was difficult and by the time
we left I felt completely drained.
Leaving unit 32 I felt many things. I was glad that had I come
and met these people, glad that I had decided to do the internship. I was exhausted
by the experience and I also felt overwhelmed by the obstacles we faced in getting
even one of them off death row.
Obviously I oppose the death penalty and my work here is to
help get people off death row. This does not mean that I believe people on
death row are innocent of crimes or that I want to see murderers running free
about the place. I simply disagree with the form of the punishment. Even if I didn’t oppose the death penalty in principle, I
would still disagree with it as it is currently practiced. It is supposed to be
for ‘the worst of the worst’, those crimes so heinous no other punishment will
do. However the inmates I have met and the cases I have read about have shown
me that all too often the death penalty is used in spurious circumstances and
applied to cases which, for lack of a better term, were that of ‘ordinary
murder’.
Prison in one thing, death is another. The two should not be
bedfellows and I stand by my opposition to the death penalty. None of the
inmates I met were the ‘worst of the worst’. So many factors come together to
result in an imposition of death – lazy criminal investigations, poor
forensics, politics, racism and poverty, among others. I have seen them all in
the cases I am involved in. What I have not seen is a verdict so secure, or a
man so monstrous that the death penalty should be imposed.